Mullberry Whine

poured out before bed

What I Read Wednesday: Bully For You

…because that’s the way we’ve always done it (Honore Daumier‘s Hydropathic Doctor)…

Medical school is an awful lot of things. It’s opportunity. It’s exciting. It’s fulfilling. But it’s also frightening. And tiring. It’s time and family and outside interest consuming. And it’s sometimes rather mean — the hierarchical training structure of medicine lends itself well to swollen egos and abuses of power.

Now in my final year of medical school (ya-hooey!), I have personally witnessed only a handful of situations involving residents or attendings flexing their mental (and physical) muscles for the younger generation in ways inappropriate. I, myself, have had extended, unpleasant interactions with only one abusive individual. My experience is much (much) tamer than that of my mentors, and theirs still tamer than the would-be healers who came before them. Yet, bullying remains a weak and mismatched thread running through the fabric of medicine. Weekly do I hear of other trainees’ uncomfortable (some of them downright national-newsworthy) experiences with demonstrative, demeaning, harassing senior members of the medical team. Unfortunately, some of the most brilliant minds in medicine are also the nastiest. And it is these people who, oftentimes by stepping on subordinates and colleagues alike, have made their way to positions of power in the medical complex.

After I had this concept slapped into me last week, I did what any bewildered seeker of higher education would do – I queried Google about bullying in medicine. Among the mish-mashery Google dumped on my screen were two articles – one quite hot off the press, the other having cooled for over a decade – which I felt compelled to share.

The more senior article is a personal views piece from across the pond in the British Medical Journal. In it, a surgical trainee recounts the abuse – and it’s awful, painful effects – suffered at the hands of a professional disembowel-er. It’s called Bullying in Medicine, having appeared in the December 1, 2001 edition of the BMJ.  I can’t help but wonder where the author is now.

The junior article, a piece from the New York Times Doctor and Patient health series, underscores research done on and efforts to squash bullying in medicine here in the US, at UCLA’s David Geffen School of Medicine. It’s entitled The Bullying Culture of Medical School, and came out just this month.  You might also peruse the original research article it highlights, Eradicating Medical Student Mistreatment: A Longitudinal Study of One Institution’s Efforts, published in the current issue of Academic Medicine.

Medicine is an amazing profession. But, like all other trades, it and those who practice it are subject to flaw – perhaps more so than many other professions because of the fierce competition to become and the overwhelming expectations for physicians. Here’s hoping victims of hierarchical abuse know they are not alone – and not in any way “weak”  for feeling bothered by said abuse.  Here’s hoping they find the wherewithal and the infrastructure that allows them to report.  Here’s hoping medical institutions create and enforce standards of collegial and interpersonal excellence at all levels of medical training.  And here’s hoping that, rather than emulating those bad actors who teach us, we can rise above them, providing the next generation of doctors good, strong mentors and role models even as we offer our patients good, strong care.


2 comments on “What I Read Wednesday: Bully For You

  1. kindredspirit23
    September 26, 2012

    It’s a shame, but it happens. Children grow up from abuse and become abusers. It’s like a legacy. It doesn’t have to happen; it can be stopped. Please stop by my friend’s blog and read her story about and ongoing recovery from abuse by a narcissist and sociopath.
    (I hope it’s alright that I mentioned that here),

    • mullberrywhine
      September 27, 2012

      Certainly I don’t mind – I’ll be sure to check it out!

Keep it clean, keep it respectful, or keep away.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Follow me.


From the Cellar

Now Fermenting

House Rules

Creative Commons License
Nothing under the table.
The views expressed on "Mullberry Whine" are NOT intended to diagnose or treat disease.
The med-ed related stories described here are based on real events. Details have been changed in accordance with HIPAA de-identification guidelines to protect confidentiality.
Mullberry Whine can be enjoyed daily; there is no unsafe quantity. Real wine, though, should be enjoyed in moderation. At-Risk Drinking for males under 65 is defined as >14 alcoholic beverages per week or >4/day, with >7 drinks a week or >3/day being the cut-off for females under 65 and for anyone, male or female, who has graced this planet for 65 years for more. Drink Mullberry Whine like there are no consequences. But drink alcohol responsibly. Your friends, your family, your health-care provider, and your liver - heck, ALL of the organs in your body - will thank you.
%d bloggers like this: